How is real estate reported on financial aid applications?
By Joe Messinger, CFP®
November 6, 2020
Determining financial aid is based on a family’s “need.” Need is determined by looking at a family’s income and assets (and in some financial aid applications, expenses like medical bills). Families often think of real estate as an asset, but real estate can take different forms–the primary residence, a second home or investment, or a business property. Let’s look at when and how real estate factors into the calculation of financial aid.
A family’s primary residence
A family’s primary residence or a family farm that is the primary residence is not included as an asset on the FAFSA or Free Application for Federal Student Aid. The FAFSA is used to determine federal financial aid including grants, loans, and work-study.
Some colleges use an institutional method to determine financial need awarded by that school, and they use the College Board’s CSS Profile application. On the CSS Profile, families are asked to provide details to determine the home equity value of their primary residence. These colleges want a more complete picture of a family’s financial status.
Not all CSS Profile universities handle home equity in the same way. Some ignore it. Some cap the home equity value at double the family’s income. Others don’t cap the amount. If a college factors home equity into their calculations, then 5% of it is then added to the Expected Family Contribution or EFC. As an example, if the family’s home equity was $400,000, a college that doesn’t cap the amount would add $20,000 to the EFC. If that same family had an income of $100,000 and the college capped the home equity value at double the family’s income, then the amount would be $200,000 times 5% or $10,000 added to the EFC.
Some people think that owning a second home and renting it out for part of the year qualifies it as a small business. Unfortunately, a rental property typically does not qualify as a small business under the FAFSA. (Family controlled small business assets are excluded from the FAFSA.) The property would need to be a more formally recognized business like a motel which provides regular maid service.
A rental property includes a unit within a family home that “has its own entrance, kitchen, and bath rented to someone other than a family member.”
The rental property’s net worth is reported as an asset on the FAFSA. Note, we said “net worth” not “market value.” To obtain the net worth, subtract the value of the property minus the outstanding debt owed on it. If the debt is higher than the value, report a zero (not a negative number). If more than one property is owned and one has a negative net worth, do not subtract that value from the net worth of the other properties. It is still treated as a net worth equal to zero.
On the CSS Profile, rental properties are also included as assets. This application will ask you for “the address, number of months your parents rented the property to others (if at all), when they bought it, how much they bought it for, the current market value and the balance of any mortgage.”
As we stated before, family owned small business (less than 100 employees) assets are excluded from the FAFSA. In most cases, rental properties are not considered a small business. However, “if the deed or title to the real estate is held by the business, as opposed to the taxpayer, it should be reported as a business asset. But if the business merely manages the real estate without owning the real estate, the real estate is not a business asset.”
If a rental property is reported on Schedule C of the IRS 1040 form, then it PROBABLY is a business asset and can be excluded from the FAFSA. However, colleges will still want to make sure that it actually qualifies as a business. The taxpayer must provide “significant services” like regular cleaning, etc. Significant services do not include providing and paying for utilities. If a property is reported on a Schedule E, then it is an investment to include on the FAFSA.
The CSS Profile does not have an exclusion for small business assets. Everything is reported.
Keeping all this in mind
When creating a college list, consider what kind of financial aid application you will need to complete and how your family’s personal situation will impact the determination of need.